I like to be polite. But i’m over polite conversation. I think people deserve the truth.
I didn’t say people deserve negativity, or truth told in a cruel way.
Here’s what got me thinking about this.
So, these kids came by the door yesterday selling magazines or something. And if they got 10,000 points, they would get a scholarship or something like that.
I don’t think this program is a good use of these kids time. So there is the truth. I’ll get back to it later.
So the kids had their speech down, and delivered it well, and were quite persistent, but the truth of my situation was I was home alone with three babies. So there is NFW, i’m going to leave my door open to two strange kids, while i get my purse to go write a check. for magazines i don’t want at all. So the problem wasn’t even so much the pitch, it was the timing of it, and also the product. I don’t want any magazines.
So then comes the counter pitch. Which was to the effect of, can you just support me then and give me an opportunity so I can work hard and achieve success like you did (man, they even write guilt into the scripts for these kids). But I come from a long line of master manipulators, and have survived and thrived at a corporate job, so I’m immune to bullshit.
Now back to that truth.
I don’t think this program is a good opportunity for these kids at all. They came dressed nicely, spoke well, and were persistent. Unfortunately, they we’rent going to reap much of the benefit of their hard work for themselves. If the goal, truly was a scholarship, then I would recommend putting that time into their studies. That way you end up with an enriched mind and the scholarship. I don’t know the details of this program, but i suspect that the bar to get the scholarship is high enough that very few kids, if any ever get it. So basically they sell some magazines for the company, and get nothing but “experience” out of the situation. Experience is good…but at that age, I really think they would have been better served investing that time into either studying or doing a free internship at a real business.
So that was my real opinion on their pitch. Is this an easy thing to say? No not really. You’re supposed to be polite and say, good for you! But is that really helping? I don’t think so. So I’d prefer to say something, in a tactful way, that I really think is helping.
so what’s the point? well, be honest. otherwise you’re not helping anyone.